View Issue Details
|ID||Project||Category||View Status||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|0022263||mantisbt||api soap||public||2017-01-26 13:35||2020-02-04 14:44|
|Summary||0022263: Mantis lacks features for automated crash reporting / "exception driven development"|
Software developers usually build exception and error reporting facility for their applications. Application should be able to automatically send bug reports for each crash. There must be a central place where all bug reports are collected (e.g. like Mantis), which may be used as TO-DO list for developers to fix bugs.
The idea here is to merge reports about the same crash (from different users) into one bug on Mantis. The more crashes bug receives - the greater priority it will have. So you can fix, say, top 3 bugs in your list - and solve the majority of problems that your users are having.
The problem is that Mantis is not suited for this kind of work. The problems are (*):
The suggestions are:
|Steps To Reproduce|
Obviosly, you can workaround Mantis problems by:
However, there are major problems with this workaround:
https://blog.codinghorror.com/exception-driven-development/ - more about the described crash reporting idea
http://help.fogcreek.com/the-fogbugz-api/bugzscout - a similar feature in Fogbugz bug tracker. Cases (bugs) about crashes are called "BugzScout cases". "Alias" is called "sScoutDescription", "count" is called "Occurrences". Scout cases can be send via usual fully-featured Fogbugz API or via dedicated "send-report-only" BugzScout API.
http://help.fogcreek.com/7566/bugzscout-for-automatic-crash-reporting - description of BugzScount simplified API.
Bugzilla also have "alias" / "bug-id" / "bug-hash" field (which is called - "alias"). JIRA has "votes" (e.g. "occurrences") and ability to search by most voted issues.
|Tags||No tags attached.|
It seems to be that you've described ABRT :-)
Incidentally, ABRT has MantisBT integration so this should suit your needs.
Honestly, Fogbuz suits my needs :)
However, we historically use Mantis.
Even if you look at ABRT: https://github.com/abrt/libreport/wiki/MantisBT - you will see that docs says it has problems, because Mantis lacks the mentioned features (unlike Bugzilla), so they have to use workarounds.
Screenshots of working feature.
This can also be integrated with 0022203
https://exceptionless.com/exceptionless-api-usage-and-overview/ - a similar feature in Exceptionless bug tracker.
A scoped token allows access only for "post event" API.
Additionally, posting event allows you to specify pre-made "reference id" (a custom ID to view bug report via web), as well as "ManualStackingKey" - for automatic merging same bug reports into one ticket with automatic increase of "Count" (e.g. same as above-discussed "alias", "bug-id", "sScoutDescription"), so you can view unique bug reports only.
|2017-01-26 13:35||GunSmoker||New Issue|
|2017-01-26 14:06||rombert||Note Added: 0055343|
|2017-01-26 14:14||GunSmoker||Note Added: 0055344|
|2017-01-26 15:04||GunSmoker||Note Added: 0055346|
|2017-01-26 15:30||GunSmoker||File Added: s1.png|
|2017-01-26 15:30||GunSmoker||File Added: s2.png|
|2017-01-26 15:30||GunSmoker||File Added: s3.png|
|2017-01-26 15:30||GunSmoker||Note Added: 0055347|
|2017-01-26 15:41||GunSmoker||Note Added: 0055348|
|2017-01-26 15:45||GunSmoker||Note Added: 0055349|
|2020-02-04 14:44||GunSmoker||Note Added: 0063581|